Monday, May 28, 2012

ISU BEKALAN AIR DI SELANGOR


Kebelakangan ini MB Selangor banyak membuat kenyataan bodoh pasai Industri Bekalan Air Selangor.......since saya terlibat diperingkat awal kajian & perancangan Selangor Water Demand Study in late 80s (kajian selama 2 tahun) dan hasilnya kita telah kenalpasti :-

1) - Menjelang 2014, Selangor & WPKL (masa tu Putrajaya not in the picture yet) dan
2) - Mencadangkan Projek Pemindahan Air drpd Pahang, kerana Selangor telah kehabisan kawasan tadahan.
30 - Menambahkan kapasiti loji rawatan Hulu Langat (skrg Langat 2)..ini kerana loji Bukit Nenas, sebarang extension or upgrading is being constraint by space, since kedudukanya diatas bukit.

Diantara kenyataan bodoh Mantan CEO PNB dan Guthrie ialah..

1) - Menggunakan Air Lombong
2) - Mencabar utk melawat ampangan2 (air tak susut konon).
3) - Menuntut RM 8 - 9 B sbg syarat pengambilan industri bekalan air Selangor oleh Pusat melalui PAAB...

Berikut adalah penjelesan layman satu persatu...

  • Fuad Omar
    A typical Water Supply and Demand Project is seeking answers to these questions:

    Is our water over-allocated?
    How do we protect groundwater? (surface water in the case of Selangor)
    How will we share during shortages?
    How do we reduce risks to water quality?
    How can we be more water efficient?
    How much water do we have?
    What does the future hold?

    http://www.obwb.ca/wsd/
    www.obwb.ca
    The Okanagan Water Supply and Demand project is the most advanced water resource...See More
    52 minutes ago · 
  • Semenyih Baru jika sejarah kekurangan air di selangor dulu berulang, rakyat yang akan menderita
    49 minutes ago · 
  • Fuad Omar http://wahidcivilengineer.blogspot.com/2011/01/kitaran-hidrologi.html ... Kajian Supply pula (Sumber Air) meliputi kajian yg komprehensif mengenai kawasan tadahan.....last slide menunjukan Simpanan Air Tawar (Ampangan yg di maksudkan oleh Khalid adalah satu sahaja)....
    wahidcivilengineer.blogspot.com
    49 minutes ago · 
  • Fuad Omar PENGURUSAN SUMBER AIR LESTARI
    Pengurusan sumber air melibatkan perancangan, analisis, penilaian,penggunaan, impak, dan ramalan terhadap sumber-sumber air secarasistematik, cekap dan optimum, tanpa membazir untuk menjamin bekalan airkepada pengguna sentiasa bersih dan berterusan.

    http://www.scribd.com/iffah%20norman/d/18992496-TEMA-4-SISTEM-HIDROLOGI
    www.scribd.com
    Scribd is the world's largest social reading and publishing site.
    47 minutes ago · 
  • Fuad Omar Oleh itu cadangan menggunakan air lombong adalah cadangan yg paling bodoh disebabkan:-
    1 - Lombong tidak mempunyai kawasan tadahan spt ampangan yg dirancang berdasarkan kajian diatas.
    2 - Selalunya air lombong tercemar oleh air kumbahan dan juga sisa lombong i.e (heavy metal)..
    3 - Simpanan air lombong bukan utk jangka masa yg panjang.
    45 minutes ago ·  ·  2
  • Fuad Omar Mencabar utk melihat paras ampangan pun juga kenyataan kebudak budakan, kerana paras ampangan akan sentiasa tinggi kerana itu sebahagian drpd operasi semua ampangan i.e bekalan air, hydro power, pertanian...melainkan ampangan tebatan banjir, ianya akan di turunkan sblm musim hujan....mcm Ampangan Batu.....apa yg perlu dilihat ialah inflow & outflow data (termasuk limpahan)...dari sini baru kita dpt reserve 2.4% yg critical itu....
    41 minutes ago ·  ·  2
  • Fuad Omar http://www.slideshare.net/icivec/topik-1-asas-hidrologi-5034017 .... lagi mengenai Kitaran Hidrologi..
    takrif hidrologi, kitaran hidrologi, kesan perubahan guna tanah, persamaan keseimbangan hidrologi
    39 minutes ago ·  ·  1
  • Fuad Omar Sebenarnya tajuk diatas kita telah belajar semasa Tingkatan 4 lagi....Physical Geography...tak tau la saya kalau Khalid tak pergi sekolah.....
    39 minutes ago ·  ·  2
  • Fuad Omar http://newportoregon.gov/dept/pwk/documents/Section06.pdf ... sepatutnya Khalid mengeluarkan Kajian Professional mcm ni utk mempertahankan kenyataan dia yg tak masuk akal tu....
    29 minutes ago ·  ·  2
  • Norazam Bin Ahmad Air lombong? Hihi
    25 minutes ago via mobile · 
  • Fuad Omar Sebaliknya Kajian ini yg depa keluarkan.....i.e cadangan utk tukar semua jamban di Selangor....yg kaya Tokeh Jamban..

    http://www.mengo.org/resources_articles/wdm_propossal_a.pdf

    Recommendations
    Each recommendation had to meet two key criteria. One, it is practical and reasonably uncomplicated to
    implement. Two, it can be implemented by the state within the existing institutional and legislative
    framework.
    Thus, to inaugurate a Water Demand Management Plan in Selangor, we humbly recommend:
    1. Require installation of water efficient toilets (minimum rating – dual flush of 6 and 3 litres) and
    plumbing fixtures in all new homes and buildings and for major renovations.
    2. Undertake to provide and install water saving bags, constant flow regulators and thimbles.
    3. Initiate, state-wide, a voluntary water efficiency certification and labelling scheme for plumbing fixtures
    and washing machines, and maintain a registry of water efficient products.
    4. Offer a RM100 rebate to replace an inefficient toilet with a high efficiency toilet and a maximum rebate
    of RM200 per home or approved establishment for 100,000 units.

    dll lain lagi....
    25 minutes ago · 
  • Fuad Omar Menuntut pampasan sehingga RM 9 B utk asset bekalan air sebagai syarat utama pengambilan bekalan air Selangor oleh PAAB....water asset as defined as follows..

    8. What kind of water assets will PAAB be taking over from the states?

    Basically, PAAB will take over the entire water system network starting from part of the pipes connecting the dam to the water treatment plant, the water treatment plant, the balancing reservoir, the servicing reservoir to the distribution pipes to the consumers.

    http://www.paab.my/inside-paab/faq#8

    Kebanyakannya adalah asset... the balancing reservoir, the servicing reservoir to the distribution pipes to the consumers...kerana yg lain2 dibiayai oleh Kerajaan Pusat..

    Oleh itu asset yg RM 9 B yg dimaksudkan oleh Khaild adalah semua pepasangan paip, rumah pam, tangki dll yg di bina oleh Pemaju Perumahan dan diserahkan kpd Kerajaan Negeri melalui PBT...

    Logik ka, Kerajaan Negeri tak keluar satu sen pun dan kos ini is "embedded" dlm kos hartanah (rumah, kedai, kilang dll) dan sudah biayar oleh pembeli hartanah tersebut......lagi pun semua projek hartanah dibangunkan semasa BN.....apa pasai Rakyat Msia perlu bayar RM 9 B kpd Kerajaan PR Selangor.....mmg tak masuk akal...
    www.paab.my
    Pengurusan Aset Air Berhad
    17 minutes ago · 
  • Fuad Omar Jadi Org Selangor....guna lah akal anda yg bijaksana utk menilai tahap IQ MB serta Kerajaan PR Selangor skrg.......
    16 minutes ago · 
  • Fuad Omar Semenyih Baru......lupakan topik sejarah....mesti jadi punya krisis bekalan air kalau Langat 2 tidak siap spt yg dijangka.....org Umno mcm hang, kalau nak buat statement kena lah confident sikit......masa kajian dulu, Putrajaya tak ujud lagi....skrg dah ada....demand mesti bertambah...tu cerita dia....tak payah sekolah tinggi nak faham.....
    12 minutes ago · 
  • Fuad Omar A key stumbling block in talks has been disagreement over the value of water assets in Selangor, estimated to be RM1 billion by Putrajaya but RM10.98 billion by the state government.

    http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/mobile/malaysia/article/selangor-seeks-out-london-law-firm-to-resolve-water-issue/

    Sorry RM 11 B, bukan 9 B (tu angka lama kot).......pasai apa dia pi jumpa Org Luar nak selesai masaalah mudah ini...
    10 minutes ago · 
  • Fuad Omar 
    However, Chin warned that PAAB could not raise bonds worth RM10.98 billion as that would lead to “rocketing” tariff hikes and said the wholly-owned Ministry of Finance Inc company was only willing to offer RM1.1 billion for Selangor’s water assets.
    http://charlessantiago.org/2010/11/08/selangor-seeks-arbitration-over-water-assets-valuation/

    Jadi kalau Pusat setuju nak bayar RM 11 B...tarif air di Selangor akan naik 11 kali ganda la....tu cerita dia..
    6 minutes ago · 
  • Norazam Bin Ahmad Mb ni dah le rupa macam karektor dlm citer the flinstones tu, akal dia pon zaman batu agaknya.
    6 minutes ago · 

No comments: